Sq Ft +/-






139 Old Barn Lane, Sagaponack

Endless Possibilities on 1.7 Acres in Sagaponack South

Nestled on a captivating 1.70 acre+/- haven in Sagaponack South, a classic Hampton contemporary, built in the early 1990’s awaits its next chapter With 4,900 SF+/- embracing 4+ bedrooms, 5 baths and a heated pool framed by verdant lawn, this East End retreat speaks to a simpler time, lovingly cared for by the same family for over 30 years. Ripe for renovation? Sure. But with the potential of a new 10,000 SF house on three levels plus pool, pool house and tennis court, an ambitious new owner might plan something more befitting this gorgeous acreage while using the current house for Summer 2024. Imagine entering your new stunning residence with over 3,500 SF+/- of luminous spaces on the ground floor which would include a new kitchen, a culinary haven adorned with the opulence of professional appliances and bespoke cabinetry.

This first-floor haven might also offer a living room with fireplace, family room, guest bedroom, a formal dining room, and a mudroom, all whispering tales of luxury. You might ascend upstairs to over 3,000 SF with the privacy of a second-level primary suite, where dreams are spun with a sumptuous sleeping chamber, walk-in closets, and an indulgent spa-like bath. Weekend entertaining would be effortless with an additional 4 guest bedrooms, dancing with sunlight, while the laundry room and linen closet weave practical elegance. Naturally, a lower level, approaching 3,000 SF, would be an ode to leisure, perhaps offering 2 bedrooms, optional bunk room, entertainment areas, wine cellar and a gym. An elevator could connect all three levels. Outside both covered and uncovered patios would provide ample space for lounging and alfresco dining while overlooking the heated Gunite pool, spa and tennis court all embraced by lawn and professional landscaping. This would not be just a home, but a sonnet of comfort and sophistication. Conveniently poised deep within Sagaponack between Bridgehampton and East Hampton, this south-of-the-highway sanctuary would be close to fine dining, chic boutiques, prestigious Hamptons golf courses and even an airport. With numerous beaches merely a short bike ride away, this new offering, ripe with potential, never before on the market, deserves your attention today.

Survey Download
Brochure Download

Property Features



Allowable Total Coverage: 29,399 SF

Coverage in the Village Incl Everything (e.g., buildings, pavement, tennis, etc.)

Your allowable Building Gross Floor Area: 6,810 SF Above Grade

Setbacks for the Principal Structure Are as Follows:

• 80′ Front 

• 25′ Min Side Yard – 65′ Total Sides 

• 100 Rear Setbacks for Accessory Structures: 

• 90′ Front 

• 30 Sides & Rear

Accessory Structures Can Not Occupy More than 20% of the Required Rear Yard

The Setbacks for Any Court Are as Follows:

• 45 Side & Rear If at Grade 

• 30 Side & Rear if Sunken

Join my mailing list today

Insider offers & new listings in your inbox every week.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact